Man,
Pretty good game. Had me at the edge of my seat at all time, and fuck me. When I went into the 'stanky room with the smell' and I tried o exit, the face didn't scare me, more or less the noise it made me shit myself lol. After that I started listening to 'I Gotta Feeling', but it couldn't hide all the sound of the game, however high I blasted it, I still heard eerie voices from the church and in the apartment. God. :p
One thing I found that stumped me in the game for quite awhile was that code for the safe in Father Vincent's closet, and I tried picture what Nathan's painting was, but never got an idea? But back to the safe - I had to cheat a little lol, by googling your game and creeping some forums on there. Finally, I found what I was looking for, and then continued on with the game.
Overall, pretty good game I'd say, very creepy at times, good graphics well planned out, might have been slightly short; and you should have made something on the lower level of the church happen - like the cross fell or something. Other than, great game, and keep up the fine work bud. :) 9/5, 5/5 :D